Use of stable isotopes in benthic organic material as a baseline for estimating fish trophic positions in lakes

Abstract

Estimating the trophic position of predators in food webs using stable isotopes requires establishing a “baseline”, typically served by bivalves or snails. However, the frequent absence of such organisms in lakes leaves researchers in a difficult situation. Here we test the hypothesis that trophic position (TP) of largemouth bass (LB; Micropterus salmoides) in lakes can be estimated from δ15N of benthic organic material (BOM) in littoral surficial sediment. δ15NLB as a function of δ15NBOM was significant across 51 lakes with an R2 of 0.84, supporting our hypothesis. In a subset of six lakes, the mean TPLB did not differ significantly when calculated using baselines of δ15N in BOM, unionid mussels (UN), gastropods (SN), or from a stable isotope mixing model. In a subset of 26 lakes, mean TPLB calculated from δ15NBOM and δ15NUN baselines were not significantly different, but TPLB calculated using δ15NBOM was not significantly correlated with TPLB calculated using δ15NUN. Although δ15NBOM should not be used interchangeably with δ15NUN as a baseline for estimating TPLB, δ15NBOM can be useful as a separate baseline where estimates of fish TP are needed in all study lakes given that mussels are frequently absent and BOM is always available for collection.