Sudden and sustained response of Acacia koa crop trees to crown release in stagnant stands

Abstract

We examined the growth response of Acacia koa Gray (koa) in dense (10 000 trees/ha), ~25-year-old, second-growth stands on Hawai‘i to crown release (thinning) and grass control. Koa diameter increment increased within 2 months of thinning across the range of residual densities (200–900 trees/ha). After 3 years, diameter increment in the most intense thinning treatment was 180% greater than in the control treatment (1.4 vs. 0.5 cm/year); in the least intense thinning treatment diameter increment was 100% greater than the control (1.0 vs. 0.5 cm/year). Koa’s growth response was independent of all measures of tree size (diameter at breast height, height, and leaf area) across the range of tree sizes sampled. A grass control treatment to determine if reduced competition for soil water would improve koa growth showed no improvement in growth response. Koa phyllode δ13C values, which represent an integrated measure of tree water status, showed no evidence of tree water stress (mean δ13C = –28.3‰) and were not significantly different between the grass removal and control treatments. These results demonstrate that koa is capable of responding quickly and positively to crown release despite years of suppressed growth and suggest that landowners interested in managing koa forests may have considerable flexibility in the timing and application of thinning treatments to koa stands.