Botulinum Toxin Accessory Proteins: Are They Just an Accessory?

Abstract

BACKGROUND Botulinum neurotoxins produced by Clostridium botulinum consist of a complex of a core neurotoxin protein and one or more nontoxin accessory proteins. The accessory proteins are generally thought to protect the neurotoxin from the gastric environment in botulism poisoning, dissociating away upon absorption. Other than their questionable immunogenicity, they are rarely mentioned in botulinum toxin therapy. OBJECTIVE To review evidence that accessory proteins potentially play a role in neurotoxin activity. RESULTS Evidence suggests that the accessory proteins do not dissociate from the neurotoxin complex and enhance neurotoxin activity. Complexed type A botulinum toxin has dramatically higher endopeptidase activity than noncomplexed neurotoxin. A primary accessory protein, hemagglutinin-33, exhibits this same effect on both type A and type E core neurotoxin proteins, the latter not natively having this accessory protein. A clinical study using an objective computer assessment assay has shown a correlation between type A complex size and glabellar strain reduction, which reflects increasing clinical efficacy. Finally, a systematic review found no correlation between type A complex size and neutralizing antibody formation. CONCLUSION Accessory proteins may play a role in the efficacy of botulinum toxin and could remain complexed to the neurotoxin for longer than previously reported.