Do We Need a Strictly Lateral Radiograph for Fracture Management of Forearm Buckle Fractures in Children?

Abstract

Objectives Buckle fractures of the distal forearm are a common fracture entity in children treated conservatively. Diagnostics primarily include radiographs in 2 planes. Inadequate images may occur in the mostly very young patients. Therefore, additional lateral radiographs are often obtained to assess a possible angular tilt. The aim of this study is to investigate whether a strictly lateral x-ray image has an influence on fracture management. Methods Seventy-three children with buckle fractures of the distal forearm were included in this retrospective analysis. All cases were analyzed by quality of radiographs, necessity to obtain an additional lateral radiograph, and what influence on fracture management resulted. Follow-up was performed 2 to 4 weeks after immobilization. Results Thirty-five girls and 38 boys with a mean age of 7.16 years were included; 40 had fractured right and 33 had fractured left arms, respectively. Isolated distal radius fractures occurred in 48 cases, isolated distal ulna fractures in 6 cases, and both bones in 19 cases. Initial radiographic images were evaluated as inadequate in 25 cases. In each of those cases, an additional lateral image was obtained by fluoroscopy without resulting in an alternated fracture management protocol, which was chosen conservatively in each case and resulted in excellent clinical outcome at follow-up examination. Conclusions Based on our results, the acquisition of additional lateral radiographs seems to be unnecessary in the diagnostic procedure of buckle fractures of the distal forearm, in case a possible palmar or dorsal angulation cannot be entirely assessed on the initial set of radiographs. An additional lateral image had no influence on fracture management, which was chosen conservatively in every case and led to excellent clinical results. Level of evidence: level III.