Practice Variation in Surgical Treatment for Lumbar Degenerative Disc Disease: Exploring Regional and Hospital Factors Influencing Surgical Rates

Abstract

Abstract Introduction: The presence of significant, unwarranted variation in treatment suggests that clinical decision making also depends on where patients live instead of what they need and prefer. Historically, high practice variation in surgical treatment for lumbar degenerative disc disease (LDDD) has been documented. This study aimed to investigate whether the dissemination of evidence-based guidelines has reduced practice variation in surgical treatment of patients with LDDD. Methods: We conducted a retrospective, cross-sectional analysis of all Dutch adults (>18 years) between 2016 and 2019. Demographic data from Statistics Netherlands were merged with a nationwide claims database, covering over 99% of the population. Inclusion criteria comprised LDDD diagnosis codes and relevant surgical codes. Practice variation was assessed at the level of postal code areas and hospital service areas (HSAs). Multivariable logistic regression analysis was employed to identify variables associated with surgical treatment. Results: Among the 119,148 hospital visitors with LDDD, 14,840 underwent surgical treatment. Practice variation for laminectomies and discectomies showed less than two-fold variation in both postal code and HSAs. However, instrumented fusion surgery demonstrated a five-fold variation in postal code areas and three-fold variation in HSAs. Predictors of receiving surgical treatment included opioid prescription and patient referral status. Gender differences were observed, with males more likely to undergo laminectomy or discectomy, and females more likely to receive instrumented fusion surgery. Conclusions and relevance: Our study highlights that the dissemination of evidence-based guidelines has contributed to a reduction in practice variation. High-quality research on effectiveness of instrumented fusion surgery is needed to decrease practice variation.