New operational quantities (RBE × D p lens/Φ) for eye lens neutron dosimetry as a function of energy and angle of incidence in the ICRU 95 formalism

Abstract

Abstract This paper is a continuation of a study published recently by the authors. It presents and discusses computed personal absorbed dose in the lens of the eye (D p lens/Φ), and a relative biological effectiveness (RBE)-weighted absorbed dose (in terms of an newly proposed operational quantity RBE × D p lens/Φ), conversion coefficients for the lens of the eye for neutron exposure at incident energies from thermal to ∼20 MeV and at angles of incidence from 0° to 90° in 15° increments, at 180° and for rotational incidence irradiation geometry (from 0° to 360° in 5° increments). These conversion coefficients were obtained from a simulation model developed for this study that contains the stylised eye model, embedded in the adult UF-ORNL mathematical phantom, whereby the previously stated RBE-weighted absorbed dose was obtained using the proposed RBE versus neutron energy distribution compiled in a previous paper by the authors. The simulations carried out for this study using the Monte Carlo N-Particle transport code version 6.2, were conducted in a realistic human eye model, for the left and right sensitive and whole volume of the lens of the eye, considering the recent proposed redefinition of the operational quantities for external radiation exposure in International Commission on Radiation Units and Measurements (ICRU) report 95. A comprehensive set of tabulated data for neutron fluence-to-dose conversion coefficients (D p lens/Φ in pGy cm2) and RBE-weighted absorbed dose (RBE × D p lens/Φ in pGy cm2) conversion coefficients is included in this paper as a function of incident neutron energy and angle of incidence. Data for D p lens/Φ (pGy cm2) are compared to similar data from the literature for validation of our model. Data for RBE × D p lens/Φ (in pGy cm2), were also compared to the equivalent operational quantity H p(3,α)/Φ (in pSv cm2) conversion coefficients calculated at 3 mm depth in a cylindrical phantom for different incident neutron energies and angles of incidence from 0° to 75° in 15° increments to demonstrate the relevance of this newly proposed operational quantity for doses resulting in tissue reactions (deterministic effects) which should be quoted in Gray (RBE-weighted absorbed dose, RBE × D (Gy)), rather than Sievert (Sv) which is reserved for stochastic effects. The current neutron weighted absorbed dose (RBE × D p lens) is proposed for the tissue reactions in the eye-lens for neutron radiation as per National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements report 180 and in line with the recent proposal for the review and revision of the System of Radiological Protection to Keeping the International Commission on Radiological Protection (ICRP) recommendations fit for purpose. This method would bring better alignment between the dose limits in ICRP 118 and the new operational quantity consistent with the units of the new eye-lens dose limits without being overly conservative. The utilization of the proposed new operational quantities, as outlined in ICRU 95, has the potential to address the ongoing challenge in enforcing regulatory limits for neutron eye dose, specifically the use of Gy instead of Sv. It should be noted that the applicability of this will vary from country to country as in many countries the legislation is likely to mandate the use of H p(3) until the regulation is amended. This approach can serve as an interim solution while awaiting the issuance of the new ICRP general recommendations, which is expected to take several years. Implementing the new operational quantities can contribute to enhancing the accuracy and effectiveness of neutron eye dose limit enforcement.