Cultivation systems for spring barley with special reference to direct drilling (1971–1974)

Abstract

SUMMARYFive cultivation systems for spring-sown barley were tested on a clay to sandy-clay loam for 4 years and their cumulative effects on soil and crop measured. Four primary cultivations in the autumn, shallow (7·5 cm), medium (15 cm) and deep (23 cm) tine cultivation and mouldboard ploughing (23 cm deep) followed in spring by secondary cultivations and sowing, were compared with direct drilling seed into uncultivated soil after controlling weeds with herbicides. At the same rates of seed and fertilizer for all systems, direct drilling and shallow cultivation yielded significantly less grain than deeper tillage in the second year only; over 4 years the differences in mean yield were small and non-significant. In terms of crop output per unit of implement net energy (estimated) direct drilling was eight times more efficient than ploughing.Direct drilling and shallow cultivation caused concentration gradients of ‘available’ phosphorus and potassium to form in the top soil. Soil strength and to a lesser extent bulk density were greater without than with cultivation but these changes had only a relatively small effect on root distribution in the profile. In untilled soil the proportion of the root system was less in the surface 2·5–12·5 cm and greater in the 12·5–32·5 cm horizon than in shallow or deep tilled soil.Mean nitrogen uptake by the crop in the third and fourth seasons was least in direct - drilled barley probably due to lower rates of mineralization of soil nitrogen in compacted than tilled soil. It was deduced that for spring barley the ‘yield plateau’ was the same for each system but that optimal rates of nitrogen would be higher for crops in untilled than tilled soils.