Mobility-oriented measurements of people’s exposure to outdoor artificial light at night (ALAN) and the uncertain geographic context problem (UGCoP)

Abstract

Advanced nighttime light (NTL) remote sensing techniques enable the large-scope epidemiological investigations of people’s exposure to outdoor artificial light at night (ALAN) and its health effects. However, multiple uncertainties remain in the measurements of people’s exposure to outdoor ALAN, including the representations of outdoor ALAN, the contextual settings of exposure measurements, and measurement approaches. Non-exposed but included outdoor ALAN and causally irrelevant outdoor ALAN may manifest as contextual errors, and these uncertain contextual errors may lead to biased measurements and erroneous interpretations when modeling people’s health outcomes. In this study, we systematically investigated outdoor ALAN exposure measurements in different geographic contexts using either residence-based or mobility-oriented measurements, different spatial scales, and multiple NTL data sources. Based on the GPS data collected from 208 participants in Hong Kong, outdoor ALAN exposures were measured from NTL imagery at 10 m, 130 m, and 500 m spatial resolutions using in-situ methods or 100 m, 300 m, and 500 m buffer zone averaging. Descriptive analysis, multiple t-tests, and logistic regression were employed to examine the differences between outdoor ALAN exposure measurements using various contextual settings and their effects on modeling people’s overall health. Our results confirmed that different contextual settings may lead to significantly different outdoor ALAN exposure measurements. Our results also confirmed that contextual errors may lead to erroneous conclusions when using improper contextual settings to model people’s overall health. Consequentially, we suggest measuring people’s exposure to outdoor ALAN using the mobility-oriented approach, NTL representation with the high spatial resolution, and a very small buffer zone as a contextual unit to derive outdoor ALAN exposure. This study articulates essential methodological issues induced by uncertainties in outdoor ALAN exposure measurements and can provide essential implications and suggestions for a broad scope of studies that need accurate outdoor ALAN exposure measurements.