Water speciation and hydrogen isotopes in hydrous stishovite: implications for the deep Earth water cycle

Abstract

AbstractStishovite is a key mineral for understanding the deep Earth water cycle because of its potential as a main carrier for water into the transition zone and lower mantle. During subduction-related metamorphism of basaltic oceanic crust, stishovite stabilizes at 8–9 GPa and comprises 10–25 vol% of the bulk mineralogy, with some experimental studies indicating that stishovite can accommodate 3.5 wt% H2O or more in the transition zone and upper lower mantle. This large water solubility has been explained by a hydrogarnet substitution mechanism (1Si4+ ↔ 4H+) and/or the incorporation of interstitial molecular water. To investigate water speciation and hydrogen isotope behavior, we synthesized partially deuterated hydrous stishovite at 9 GPa and 450 °C in a multi-anvil press (MA). The hydrous stishovite contains on average 1.69 ± 0.05 wt% water, which is consistent with earlier MA studies but is significantly lower than the 3.5 wt% reported from in situ diamond anvil cell (DAC) studies made at higher pressures and temperatures. 1H MAS NMR spinning sideband characteristics suggest a high abundance of interstitial molecular water in hydrous stishovite, while the presence of a hydrogarnet defect cannot be ruled out. Unit-cell volumes and deuterium enrichment in the quenched hydrous stishovite indicate that ~ 45% of the water is lost from the stishovite upon quenching and decompression of the experiment, consistent with a higher solubility. This implies that the pristine water contents of a P–T–fO2 equilibrated hydrous stishovite cannot be quenched to 1 atm and room temperature from classical MA experiments. We further present a capillary-based recovery method for fluid from experimental capsules, allowing direct determination of the D/H ratio of the experimental fluid and indirect determination of the hydrous stishovite. Using Rayleigh modeling to account for the quench-related water loss, we find that, at 450 °C and 9 GPa, deuterium is 3.5–4.5 times enriched in hydrous stishovite relative to coexisting aqueous fluid. This is opposite of what is commonly observed for mineral–fluid pairs above 300 °C, rendering hydrous stishovite a potential sink for deuterium and decreasing the D/H ratio of coexisting aqueous fluids. Partial decomposition (30–60%) of hydrous stishovite during mantle upwelling and production of primary basaltic melts could be accompanied by high-temperature D/H fractionation, decreasing the hydrogen isotope composition of such melts towards “mantle-like” δD values between −75 and −220‰.